|
Graphology is the study of handwriting and its connection to behavior, personal information and other human traits. Many graphologists claim to be able to deduce personal information from the handwriting of strangers, including such things as determining where a person is from. Although graphology is widely used in both unofficial and official capacities around the world, it is scorned by many scientists due to a shortage of supporting empirical evidence.
Graphology is based upon a number of basic assertions:
- The written movement is under the direct influence of the central nervous system which comprises the brain, the cerebellum and the spinal fluid. The form of the written movement is not modified by the hand if it functions normally and is sufficiently well adapted to its function.
- When we write, the 'ego' is active but it is not always active to the same degree. Its activity comes and goes, waxes and wanes; being at its highest level when an effort has to be made by the writer and at its lowest level when the motion of the writing organ has gained momentum and is driven by it.
- We cannot voluntarily modify our natural writing at any given time without putting into it the marks of the effort required to obtain the change.
- The writer who writes under circumstances where the action of writing is particularly difficult, will instinctively use either the forms of letters which are most familiar to him, or forms of letters which are simplest and easiest to write.
- The physiological mechanism which produces the written movement correlates with the state of the central nervous system and varies in accordance with it. The written strokes, therefore, correspond to the constitutional varieties of the nervous system and to the momentary modifications of each nervous system.
- One must examine the significance of a handwriting trait by considering it as a physiological movement, and by comparing the quality, overall size, regularity, and consistency of energy with the corresponding psychological movement.
- There are no independent signs; there are only general indications which may have different forms. The significance of these can be assessed accurately by tracing them back to their origins and adapting the meaning of the latter to the conditions of the milieu in which the form appears.
- One graphological sign does not necessarily represent a single character trait. For example, rising handwriting may indicate ardour, activity, ambition, momentary joy or folly. The value of a sign depends upon its cause, its context and its intensity. Such vagueness is one of the key points of attack for critics, since most graphology "rules" can apparently be altered at the whim of the test-giver.
Principles of graphology
Graphology is rife with practitioners of one approach calling practitioners of the other approach charlatans, frauds, and the like. Carroll v State
[ 276 Ark 160; 634 SW 2d 99, 101-102 (1982) ] being a demonstration of just what each side resorts to, when push comes to shove, in the courtroom.
The approaches to handwriting analysis are:
- This is also known as 'fixed signs','trait stroke', 'French System' and Graphoanalysis®.
- The basic theory is that stroke formations relate to specific personality traits. For example, the letter "t" with the bar crossing above the stem, indicates daydreaming. A crossing at the line indicates distant goals.
- There is no published research indicating the accuracy of any of the traits used by any of these systems of handwriting analysis. There are some studies which imply that the approach as a whole has merit. Crumbaugh, James C & Stockholm, Emilie (1977) ("Validation of Graphoanalysis by 'Global' or 'Holistic' Method." Perceptual And Motor Skills April 1977, 44(2), 403-410.) being the most significant one.
- This is commonly, but incorrectly referred to as 'Gestalt Graphology'. Gestalt Graphology was a system of handwriting analysis developed circa 1920 in Germany.
- In this approach a personality profile is constructed on the basis of combining different things in the script, such as polarity, margins, pressure and spacing.
- In this approach, one looks for symbols seen in the handwriting. For example, John Wayne's signature shows a blackened out portion, that represents his lung cancer.
Applications of graphology
The most common applications of graphology are:
- Employment profiling
- Marital compatibility
- Psychological analysis
- Medical diagnosis
Employment profiling
A company takes a writing sample provided by you, and proceeds to do a profile, to see how well your personality suits the desired job.
The research results range from failure ( Lighton, R E
A Graphological Examination of the Handwriting of Air Pilots
Thesis in the Faculty of Arts: University of Pretoria: 1934) to guarded
success (Luca, E S
"Major Aptitudes and Personality Chracteristics of 42 Dental Students as Evaluated Through their Handwriting."
New York Journal of Dentistry
1973, 43, 281 - 283)
The use of graphology in the hiring process has been criticized on ethical ground ( Daryl Koehn "Handwriting Analysis In Pre-Employment Screening" The Online Journal of Ethics
Vol. 1 * No. 1 * Article 1 ) and on legal grounds
( Julie Spohn "The Legal Implications of Graphology"
Washington University Law Quarterly
Vol. 73 * No. 3 * Fall 1997)
An additional service, offered by some graphologists, is to say how well the person will fit in with your current employees.
According to the BBC, 3,000 employers in the United Kingdom use graphologists as part of their recruitment process.
Privacy considerations
Very often graphologists will state that handwriting analysis in the workplace is legal, and cite any one or more of the following cases:
- 388 US 263-267 (1967)
- 410 US 1 (1973)
1973, Lawyers Edition, Second Series 35, 67
93 SC 774
- 410 US 19 (1973)
- 547 F 2nd 249 ( CA 4th 1977 )
- 388 US 218, 221-223 (1967)
They are all related to obtaining samples for comparison with documents, sound recordings etc and used to determine whether or not the individual who provided the sample, is the same person as created the evidence that they have.
Nothing to do with permission to do a psychological analysis is even implied.
Marital compatibility
This consists of doing a psychological portrait of each individual, and seeing where their personality traits are compatible or not.
Psychological analysis
It is claimed that people's handwriting gives clues to both their personality and their mental state. These reports can range from a ten item check off list, to a 10,000 word report.
Medical diagnosis
Probably the aspect of handwriting analysis with the most quackery associated with it, and also with the most research done into it.[Kanfer] claimed that he could detect cancer from an analysis of handwriting, years before doctors could detect it. Subsequent studies failed to support his findings.
Criminal investigation
A discipline of handwriting analysis better known as questioned document examination is used extensively within the United States court system in order to identify or eliminate an individual as being the writer of a particular piece of handwriting.
- Goodtitle Drevett v Braham 100 Eng Rep 1139 (1792) is reportedly the first case at which the testimony of a questioned document examiner was accepted.
- Cameron v Knapp, 137 Misc. 2d 373, 520 N.Y.S.2d 917 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. 1987) (handwriting expert may testify as to the authenticity of a writing but not as to an individual's physical or mental condition based on a handwriting sample) stands as current U.S. case law for the rejection of graphology as psychological testimony.
- Carroll v State probably will be best remembered for why graphologists should not be allowed to testify.
Divination
Handwriting is believed by some to hold information about one's future. This application of graphology requires a belief in the supernatural. The code of ethics for the International Graphoanalysis Society
prohibits the practice of anything related to the occult.
See also
External links
|
